首页 > 待弃文存 > 蓟门法哲学研习会2017-2018专题研讨(十三):The Service Conception: Reasonal Belief and Authority-Determining Rightness(二)

蓟门法哲学研习会2017-2018专题研讨(十三):The Service Conception: Reasonal Belief and Authority-Determining Rightness(二)

报告主题:

The Service Conception: Reasonal Belief and Authority-Determining Rightness

报告人:

薛鸣秋(北伊利诺伊大学哲学系2018级硕士研究生)

评议人:

王昱博(中国政法大学法学院法学理论2014级硕士研究生)

内容简介:

The service conception of authority consists of three conditions the satisfaction of which according to Raz, leads to the justification of the preemptive force of the alleged authority. It also presupposes the reasonable belief condition (RBC) according to which if the alleged authority is to be justified, it must be reasonable for the subject to believe that the authority satisfies the three conditions, and the authority-determining rightness condition (ADR) which argues that if the alleged authority is to be justified, its directive must at least partly determine the rightness of the instructed act. However, in coordination cases, the typical cases of the service conception where ADR and other conditions can be satisfied, the alleged authority cannot create preemptive reasons. Furthermore, even if we reject the preemption thesis, understanding legitimate authority in analogy with theoretical authority, the service conception can only be applied to a rather limited range in the political context, because RBC cannot be satisfied, on account of the existence of widespread and deep disagreements among citizens. Thus, the service conception fails as a theory of political authority. We should either abandon the instrumental approach to the problem of authority while insisting on the preemption thesis, or acknowledge the impossibility of developing a normative account of authorities in general while understanding authority in analogy with theoretical authority.

时间:2018年6月24日下午2:00-5:30

地点:中国人民大学泊星地咖啡馆

欢迎参加。

分类: 待弃文存 标签: 321
  1. 本文目前尚无任何评论.
  1. 本文目前尚无任何 trackbacks 和 pingbacks.